Drive on Over: Where to Find the Best Pizza Near Muncie, IN

Whether you’re feeding your family or treating your coworkers, pizza is one thing you can’t go wrong with. Select your new favorite pie from these best pizza spots in Muncie, IN.

1. Greek’s Pizzeria

The heartwarming story of Greek’s starts with a self-taught 14-year-old pizza progeny. Located at 1600 W University Ave, this eatery is now locally owned and operated and serves the community with a delectable menu. Start with freshly made breadsticks brushed with their signature garlic butter while you decide which pie to order.

Choose between specialty pizzas like their Gourmet Grilled Chicken Ranch with Indiana bacon and garlic ranch butter, or the Grilled Chicken Fajita with green bell peppers and jalapenos. If you can’t decide, create your own pizza with their customizable options.

2. Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders

At 4116 W Bethel Ave, you’ll be greeted with the tantalizing smell of freshly baked bread and hand-tossed pizza dough. Start with an appetizer like Tomato Cheese Bread or French fries, then indulge in a hand-crafted Cowboy Steak grinder with ribeye steak, jalapenos, bacon, and chipotle ranch. Specialty pies include the Mancino’s Pride, made with ham, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives.

Select your drink from a menu of local and national beers and wine including a rotating list of microbrewery gems. Alcohol is intended for adults of legal drinking age only. Please remember to drink responsibly and in moderation, and never drink and drive.

3. The Guardian Brewing Co.

The independently owned craft brewery perched at 514 E Jackson St does more than provide Muncie with high-quality beers, wines, and ciders. On the food menu, you’ll find vegan-friendly crusts and beer-infused pizza sauces, all made with fresh ingredients.

The menu includes many creative pies, including the Crust Punk Deluxe with garlic aioli, a Charlie cream ale base, steak, chicken, bacon, and topped with their house 3 Pepper Drizzle made of chipotle, serrano, habanero, raspberry, and Rainbow Pop. Ask your server for drink recommendations for impeccable pairings fresh from the brewery!

4. Johnny Carino’s

Pile the family into your 2023 Toyota Tundra Platinum and head over to 1101 W McGalliard Rd for incredible Italian bites, from classic dishes like lasagna, fettuccine alfredo, and of course – pizza! All pizzas are created with housemade dough and can be optionally paired with unlimited Caesar salad or a cup of soup.

Mouthwatering options include the Traditional Margherita made with fresh basil, the Pepperoni & Pepperoni with layers of pepperoni, and Johnny’s Favorite, made with applewood smoked bacon, sausage, pepperoni, black olives, mushrooms, and green bell peppers.

When you’ve tried a slice of taco pizza or filled up on garlic breadstick knots, swing by Toyota of Muncie to see what’s in stock!

Tags: food, Muncie IN, pizza, pizzeria
Posted in Things To Do in Muncie, IN | No Comments »